WHEN SHOULD AN ATHLETE SAY NO?

A HOBBLED RG3

A HOBBLED RG3

Interesting that the discussion coming out of yesterday’s NFC Wildcard game between the Washington Redskins and Seattle Seahawks (24-14, Seattle) revolves around ‘Skins rookie QB Robert Griffin III’s decision to start, and then stay in the game after it became apparent to anyone with working optic nerves that he wasn’t the same RG3 who so captivated the NFL and the nation’s capital this season with his combination of lightning foot speed and accurate throwing arm.

Last year’s Heisman Trophy winner out of Baylor University didn’t even need to get hit to illustrate – quite painfully in the first quarter – that his injured right knee was not only not healed, but instead fully compromised, thereby robbing him of the very skill-set that made him such a potent threat.  Well, it was apparent to everyone, it seems, except Redskins head coach Mike Shanahan.

“Robert said to me, ‘Coach, there’s a difference between injuries and being hurt. I can guarantee I’m hurting right now, give me a chance to win this football game, because I guarantee I’m not injured.’,” Shanahan told Yahoo Sports. “That was enough for me.”

Regardless of where you come down on the “He shouldn’t have been playing or kept playing” continuum, what is also quite apparent is the vast difference in mentality between a team sport like football, where there is something beyond the self to play for – as muddled as that sometimes gets – and the sport of athletics which has reduced itself to the individual athlete representing nothing but him or herself.

Systems create realities.  Thus, how many times have we heard a runner, thrower or jumper claim just the opposite of what RG3 was claiming in the lead up to a major marathon or track meet?  Except for very obvious cases like Chinese high hurdler Liu Xiang, who attempted to start the 2008 Beijing Olympic 110-meter hurdles despite an injured Achilles tendon, it seems like any little twinge or niggle is enough to knock a track athlete off the start line, no questions asked.  But that’s what happens in a sport where A) the money is so short, B) base compensation is tied to automatic reduction clauses in shoe contracts and year-end rankings, C) every payday has to count.  Nobody goes unless they are 100%.

Athletics has designed an all-or-nothing system built around the clock, measuring tape and individual athlete.  That system has consistently held fan interest as a secondary goal, at best.  Again, how often have we in the media had to explain right off the bat why half the field that was announced to be competing is now not coming? Or, instead of the two big names in an event going head-to-head, we see two separate events staged at the same meet with the outcomes of place all but predetermined?  The whole system is utterly counter-intuitive to building interest.

Odd, too, because American football, as punishing a game as there is, has contracts which aren’t guaranteed either.  But, just look what happens if you do sit out a game with an injury in football.  Ask Drew Bledsoe, the former #1 overall draft pick out of Washington State and franchise QB for the New England Patriots.  He never got his starting position back after Tom Brady came in to replace him following a rib injury in the middle of the 2001 season for the Super Bowl bound Pats.  Ask current S.F. 49’er QB Alex Smith who still sits on the bench after he was forced to the sidelines with a concussion and Colin Kaepernick came in to electrify the 49’er offense, even though Smith was among the league leaders in QB rating.

That’s why men like Griffin are so reluctant to give up their starting job.  That’s why the NFL has created this uber-macho world view.  Who knows what a subsequent MRI will show to be the extent of RG3’s knee injury?  He could well have jeopardized his entire career with this one youthfully exuberant – but fully understandable – decision.  His knee sure went all wobbly in the wrong direction when he attempted nothing more than to pick up that bad snap near the goal line in the fourth quarter.  Of course, that’s why there are supposed to be coaches around to think long rather than short term.

Follow up medical tests will tell a huge tale going forward for 2013 -`14 season and beyond.  But what the Redskins needed yesterday in order to go forward with a chance to play next weekend in the playoffs was for backup QB Kirk Cousins to get the start or the early relief call when it was obvious that Griffin was not RG3, especially since Cousins had previously proven himself an able replacement in week 15 after RG3 injured his knee the week before.  Unfortunately, by the time Coach Shanahan got around to putting Cousins in to replace his hobbled teammate midway through the fourth quarter, the game was already out of reach.

This much is certain, if RG3 was still a record-setting intermediate hurdler, as he was at Copperas Cove High School and Baylor University, you can bet the farm he wouldn’t have been in the blocks yesterday.

END

About these ads

One comment on “WHEN SHOULD AN ATHLETE SAY NO?

  1. Rico says:

    When the coach asks the pitcher if he can continue in inning 9 of World Series game 7, pitcher says, “hell yes”. Coach, who has watched him pitch all season and knows what he sees, pulls him, pitcher throws fit, team wins, pitcher mad enough to train harder in off-season. If RGIII said he wanted to come out, he’s not RGIII. Rookie takes bad team to playoffs, shows what future can be. What, were they going to go on a “run for the ages” and win it all? With your raison d’etre less than 100%? First off, he wasn’t even RGIII in that game. Give your backup, a good player, some playing time. Stunned that Shanahan is so naive/spineless/short-sighted. Even if he does come back, his career will be less than it would have been.

    US mens distance runners had the big downtime due imo to their lack of real coaching and meaningful team membership. Seemed a great life – do your own thing, individual, etc. US women had success imo because they had a coach and teams. Real men don’t need coaches. US men started back with coaches and real training groups, and started having success. “Real” coach and “real” training group usually does not mean their college configuration, though that can work for a little while. Real means professional, in all dimensions. Ryan Hall and Jeremy Warner leave their “real” coaches, and yeah, that. Coaching seems so simple. Hand out the workout, stand there with a watch, say “looking good” every now and then. Yeah, I can do that. Turns out the real value is when to tell them to do less. “Hay is in the barn”, as Bill Bowerman would say. And he apparently had to threaten Kenny Moore with a 2×4 to keep him from running too much. Most don’t need motivation, that’s why they’re world class. They need someone to tell them when its enough, more is less, etc. And the athlete needs to trust them. Alan Webb and coach too insecure to know, so he sets “WR” for April” (kind of like HR record in minors?), then real WR in July when Olympics is in Aug/Sept. Oops. Everyone beating us had coaches, training partners, and training programs. Need not be fancy, just needs to be there.

    Tony, love all your stuff, thanks for your career, and please keep us going.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s