MAKING A MOCKERY OF COMPETITION

Geoffrey Mutai holds on in Berlin

     Geoffrey Mutai’s one-second win at Sunday’s BMW Berlin Marathon all but sewed up the 2011-2012 World Marathon Majors series title for the 31 year-old Kenyan star, and the $500,000 bonus that attends it.  With wins in Boston and New York City in 2011, Mutai added 25 more points for his 2:04:15 win over fellow Kenyan Dennis Kimetto in Berlin, giving him 75 WMM points over the course of the two-year cycle.  The WMM title and bonus are Mutai’s unless another Kenyan, 2011 Chicago runner-up and 2012 Boston Marathon champion Wesley Korir ( 40 points) can manage the unlikely double of winning this weekend’s BofA Chicago Marathon (25 pts), and then turn around and finish no worse than third in New York City November 4th  (10 pts).  That would tie Korir with Mutai at 75 points, but earn Korir the series title in a tie-breaker, as he bested Mutai head-to-head in the sweltering heat of Boston 2012 where Mutai dropped out.

Needless to say, that scenario is highly improbable.

But Mutai only won Berlin by a scant second over his training partner Dennis Kimetto.  And this is where things get dicey.  On paper a one-second margin would suggest a titanic final meters drama to decide the issue -

Thrill of Victory

think Mo Farah’s double Olympic distance wins in London where the mask of anxiety and exhilaration warped his features as he held victory so close.

Instead, debuting marathoner Kimetto sat on Mutai’s left shoulder throughout the final two kilometers in Berlin acting more like a wing-man than a competitor.  Mutai, we found out afterwards, was done in after 35 kilometers by a sour stomach leaving him unable to drive or push, and seemingly leaving him vulnerable to any sort of challenge.  Yet none was forthcoming.

Immediately, one concluded that the apprentice, Kimetto, was not going to beat his mentor, Mutai, and thus deprive him of the $500k World Marathon Majors bonus. If Kimetto had won, it’s not like he would have earned the half-million dollar bonus.  Rather, it would only have increased Wesley Korir’s chances, as a second place by Mutai in Berlin would have meant that Korir would only need a win in Chicago to supplant Mutai as the series winner.  As my friend Ed Caesar - who is writing a book on the two-hour marathon while living in Iten, Kenya – said:  “(If Kimetto had won) everyone in the small village where Mutai and Kimetto live (Kapn’gtuny) would have lost.”

This is the second time in the World Marathon Majors series history that a training partner has seemed to back off in the final stretch to allow his compatriot to win and collect the series bonus. In 2007, Robert Cheruiyot was on his way to his third of four Boston Marathon titles.  But in the final two kilometers his training partner James Kwambai was still at his shoulder.  As the two men headed into Kenmore Square with one mile to go, Kwambai peeled off to grab water while Cheruiyot didn’t.  Then, in seemingly leisurely fashion, Kwambai stayed behind his mate all the way to the Boylston Street, finishing 20-seconds back.  No attempt was made to close the gap even though Kwambai seemed unfazed by effort or pain.

Now we’ve seen a similar circumstance in Berlin.  Kimetto’s consolation was a world marathon debut record 2:04:16, seven-seconds faster than Ayele Abshero ran to win the Dubai Marathon this January.

This isn’t just a World Major Marathons issue.  Before the series ever began in 2006, we witnessed another such training partner run-in over the final meters in Berlin.  In 2003 Paul Tergat was on his way to his marathon world record 2:04:55 while his friend and pacer, Sammy Korir stayed with him through the Brandenburg Gate, but just a few steps behind, never seeking to overtake Tergat for the win.

Only once in WMM history has the men’s title come down to a head-to-head showdown to decide the whole shootin’ match.  That, of course, was the now famous 2010 final 5K battle between eventual champion Sammy Wanjiru of Kenya and Ethiopia’s Tsegaye Kebede on the streets of Chicago.

But with finishing times and record performances having taken center stage in this sport for the last 20 years, this system of inviting training partners to major marathons to go for world records has produced protected wins that make a mockery of the essence of sport, competition.  This cannot be the outcome the five World Marathon Majors had envisioned, can it?

END

About these ads

8 comments on “MAKING A MOCKERY OF COMPETITION

  1. [...] Pro news Berlin marathon fallout. Geoffrey Mutai won the Berlin Marathon yesterday and clinched the World Marathon Majors title and the $500,000 prize that goes with it. But Mutai’s training partner, Dennis Kimetto, was only one second back at the finish and appeared content to let Mutai win. Obviously, this raises serious questions about the integrity of the competition. [...]

  2. Jack Vail says:

    Toni , pure 100% speculation. My suggestion is that you as journalist and held in high regard in the sport do some research , maybe even ask the question to Mr. Kimetto and Mr Mutai to talk about the finish. Not what you observed or what your friend thinks.
    What you can be accurate about is that winner take all in WMM structure was not well thought out and does not give incentive for a real race for a number of athletes.

  3. Toni Reavis says:

    Jack,

    Absolute speculation, couldn’t agree more. But it’s born out of 30+ years of watching marathons closely, and knowing how systems and athletes work. The picture of Mr. Kimetto with his hands to his face in the final strides (in disbelief at the time he has run in his debut) is testament enough to his willingness to let Mr. Mutai cross in front of him. Not saying it’s wrong. In fact, I would have been shocked to see him take advantage of Mutai’s vulnerability. And I wouldn’t expect either Mutai or Kimetto to admit they finished this way on purpose.
    \\
    In 2004 at the Rock `n` Roll Half Marathon in Virginia Beach Haron Toroitich was in position to pick up a $25,000 bonus for winning his second RnR title of the year. His training partner, Joshua Chelanga ran alongside down the boardwalk. Then, just steps from the finish, he backed off to let Haron take the win and the bonus. When I asked afterwards, there was a sly grin, nothing more. When you’ve seen it before, you know when you see it again. Especially when the bonus is half-million dollars US.

  4. [...] in Berlin, with that sham of a finish, is a last straw (read my account here and one by Toni Reavis here). Far from accomplishing whatever it was allegedly set up to achieve, the series is now doing [...]

  5. Jeremy says:

    Are you serious? This is their job. It is not a competition as the white people would like to think it is. We sit on our couches, or even run in the middle of the pack, and expect our champions to “do the sport proud”. Let’s be honest: These guys are running to feed their family, friends, and community. We put up the prize money with our outsized entry fees and big advertising dollars and these guys are doing exactly what they set out to do: take that money home with them. I don’t know why we make a big deal about whether or not they ran their hardest or made for a thrilling TV finish, when in fact, they already won their battle when they trained their bodies to unimaginable levels by pushing through pain and sacrificing more heavily than most of us can only imagine-because that is what they do, every day, to feed themselves. I have no issue with the way things played out in Berlin. Those guys earned every dollar!

  6. pcunite says:

    I have to say that professionals won this race … did not Lance have a team to “let” him win too?

  7. [...] In the women’s race Atsede Baysa edged Rita Jeptoo by one second, 2:22:03 to 2:22:04.  It was great to see a close finish between two runners where both actually appeared to be trying. [...]

  8. [...] “This [Berlin controversy] cannot be the outcome the five World Marathon Majors had envisioned, can it?” yelled Toni Reavis. [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s